By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

  1. Welcome to the 12ozProphet Forum...
    You are currently logged out and viewing our forum as a guest which only allows limited access to our discussions, photos and other forum features. If you are a 12ozProphet Member please login to get the full experience.

    Please note, if you are a 12ozProphet Member and are locked out of your account, you can recover your account using the 'lost password' link in the login form. If you no longer have access to the email you registered with, please email us at [email protected] and we'll help you recover your account.

...if you kill 100 terrorists, is it worth 10 innocent lives?...

Discussion in 'Channel Zero' started by mental invalid, Sep 17, 2001.

  1. mental invalid

    mental invalid Dirty Dozen Crew

    Joined: May 11, 2001 Messages: 13,050 Likes Received: 8
    ...is it right to kill innocent in order to kill the guilty? are 10 lives worth 100 kills...as we gear up for an attack, and we try to cut through the political rhetoric, and breathe wisdom through the anger, we will be faced with this question...and in societies like the middle east where government/culture/religion/terrorism seem to go hand in hand, how effective will we be in seperating the innocent...and how innocent are they in fact...there is this talk of afghanistan and yet did you recognize that the terrorist were mostly from other countries...some even 'friendly' countries...so now it seems how do we eradicate this threat, that prospers in an area, not just a nation, which is so embroiled in hate...we can kill bin laden but more importantly how do we change our policies in order to change the middle east perceptions and behaviours towards us...cause anyone who thinks that if you kill a few terrorist it will all just go away, is not only neglecting the major problems and issues in the middle east since the 40's, but also the past 2,000 years...

    jumping in tangents
  2. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    and who are we to o.k. such acts. i really think it deserves more consideration, and consensus, rather than throwing away our money and votes blindly at a war against the more radical factions of our society. i mean we created it did we not, must we therefore now live with it, good and bad. and on that, people are not in it for the long term. they are all about immediate gratification. who but we judge ourselves, and if we fail to do so, who can take our place. and i'm not sure who these words are directed at, most of "modern" society i guess. i guess when you have a world which you call your mother, and you treat her with disrespect, you cannot help but live in fear and loathing. but what can we do, we were rolling the rock up the hill before we were born, as long as we keep it rolling well we have not to worry? . .we need to come together and try to solve some of this thing before we get flattened by it. the headache was gone for a minute, i'm afraid it's back. i mean we can go on believing that politicians are genuine and good despite what hateful things they say to one another, and the actions some have taken(whether for punishment of the guilty or not, or our "wellbeing"), and that they may be, but the cumulative effect of the latter is not to be taken soooo lightly. i cannot help thinking what will happen if everyone continues to not keep track of what is going on. headache's aside, the time is ripe for some deep consideration of our willful participation in the downfall of earth, from a personal level with a global perspective (whatever the hell that means). what does it mean to be a citizen of this democracy and leader of so many?
  3. eros

    eros Senior Member

    Joined: Aug 3, 2000 Messages: 1,033 Likes Received: 0
    I couldn't agree more. I have playing with the possibilities in my head for days, and none of it has a positive outcome.
  4. boogie hands

    boogie hands 12oz Legend

    Joined: Feb 15, 2001 Messages: 16,059 Likes Received: 13
    well the first thing we can do is stop commiting acts of terror on other nations....weve commited comperable acts (as far as lives lost) against other contries with not so much as a peep made about it....but now it happens the good old USA and we want the entire world to back us in a war....
    another step we could take is stop enacting sanctions on these middle eastern countries....so we stop incoming medical supplies and food....has this ever had an effect on anyone who was actually harming us??? mabey if we were fighting a war on children we would be winning but as far as i can see innocent people are the only ones weve hurt....
    yes, weve jumped to the aid of a huge amount of countries in their times of distress but if timothy mcveigh had devoted the rest of his life to vouleteer work at the local hospital would we have excused what he did....hell no and the US is no exception our goverment handles its self in an unaceptable manner and honestly....is on the same level as the people were fighting....the sad part is that in war and politics taking innocent life is worth more than actually destroying the root of the problem....i wouldnt doubt if you see this practice enacted in the next couple of weeks, that is if the news decides to show you....

    brick, brick ,brick...thats how i be up against your girlfriends ass...

    [This message has been edited by boogie hands (edited 09-17-2001).]
  5. TOY

    TOY New Jack

    Joined: May 16, 2001 Messages: 2 Likes Received: 0
    it like this...10 innocent people is better than the thousands (or even more) of innocent people 100 terrorists can kill.
  6. BizOne

    BizOne Senior Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 1,044 Likes Received: 0
    When we thought terrorist were still flying in the air, we were going to shoot them down. There were only a few terrorist on the plane with the majority of the passengers being our own people, but we were going to kill them all because if we didn't, the terrorist would probably end up killing a lot more than what's in the plane.

    Same thing here.

    I'm sure if we could go to Afghanistan and take out all the innocent people before we bomb it, we would.... But it's an unrealistic thought.

    We're going to be targeting terrorists though. So if any innocent people are hanging around terrorist hideouts, then maybe they're not so innocent.

    Why are so many people against bombing though? Picture it on a smaller level. Say for instance that 2 people in the house next to you (people who you never speak with, not friends in this case) kill your entire family, even your dog or cat.... Now, would you care about killing the other three people in that house, or would you just send a hand grenade through the fucking kitchen window?
  7. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    1)first argument, nonsense, you're not killing the innocent to get to the terrorist, you are dismatling a potentially deadly weapon, not the same thing.

    2)Afganistan is a fucked up place, and i'm sure not all the innocent are prepared to leave their homeland despite the risk of sure death.

    3)all right, this last part really gets my goat. you are making no cense what so ever here, for instance, you forget that maybe we don't want to spend the rest of our lives in jail, or that maybe we have certain misgivings about killing things, and you have to add that those two people you are taking out may or may not be responsible for the deaths of your family, and even if you strongly suspected it you probably wouldn't be able to tell for sure. you may have the deaths of five instead of three innocents on your hands and have solved nothing.

    i don't know much, but i think alot of people are talking alot without thinking what hateful messages might be coming across. i certainly hope that it's just the immediacy of the events of last week talking, and not their acutal beliefs.
  8. BizOne

    BizOne Senior Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 1,044 Likes Received: 0
    I don't agree with anything you've said and you made a really weak argument.

    To be honest, I think you sound like a closed-minded pussy! [​IMG]
  9. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    yeah, good come back. you're a blood thirsty masochist, and i think you suck eggs through garden hoses.
  10. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    close minded, you're the one talking about possibly slaughtering five innocent people, close minded are you fucking kidding me.
  11. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    ok, ok, bin laden's not so innocent, but i am going to say you haven't got the slightest clue as to the meaning of what's going on, you say that it's like killing a whole family to kill the two people that killed your family, or wait maybe it wasn't YOUR family, maybe it was someone elses boat that they wrecked, or the family dog like three years ago. well that's what we're talking about isn't it, but in real life you WOULD do jail time for that, who makes america pay, we don't answer to anyone except ourselves, the rest of the world just sits around and thinks about how to diplomatically tell us what we're doing is wrong until it's all over. don't tell me i'm close minded without having any argument to back it up.
  12. BizOne

    BizOne Senior Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 1,044 Likes Received: 0
    Okay, since we're going to be bombing the terrorists, then why would so many innocent people be hiding out in their caves with them!?

    Don't worry about the innocent. If they are innocent we'll be sending them to a better place, right?
  13. Mr.LonelyHeart

    Mr.LonelyHeart Member

    Joined: Aug 31, 2001 Messages: 994 Likes Received: 0
    you may be right, but is there any chance you could list any of these "comparable acts(as far as lives lost)"? I'd sincerely like to know the last time some US citizens murdered more than 5400(and the number keeps rising) innocents in one day. 75 were killed at waco, and 168 at the Oklahoma city bombing...but those are still only small fractions of 5000+... If you do know of any that come close to the magnitude of this recent attack (in recent years) I think we all ought to know. Peace.
  14. 23578

    23578 Elite Member

    Joined: Jul 2, 2000 Messages: 2,521 Likes Received: 0
    we don't go to caves and bomb them, we bomb THINGS from the sky, and from far away, and the caves go untouched for the most part that's why.

    Mr. LonelyHEart-Iraq, Iraq, Iraq. and in our own country, thousands upon thousands die from lack of healthcare, and malnutrition: our argument "ANYBODY can get a job right now." there's plenty of fuel for that fire.
  15. dr. frink one

    dr. frink one Elite Member

    Joined: Jun 7, 2001 Messages: 3,638 Likes Received: 1
    where is seeking on this one...
    wisdom is needed